You've successfully subscribed to Dr. Jon 🎸
Great! Next, complete checkout for full access to Dr. Jon 🎸
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all content.
Success! Your billing info is updated.
Billing info update failed.
Authenticity in Music

Authenticity in Music

What does it mean to be an authentic musician?

Jonathan Smith
Jonathan Smith

My favorite recordings, performances, and compositions feel authentic.

What is authenticity?

Authentic is defined by Merriam-Webster as:

But, what is authenticity in music?

It may mean something slightly different to everyone, but most may agree that authentic music has meaning, personality, and originality. When a great performer delivers like they wrote the song or composition, I am moved by it's honesty. When they show their true character with and without words, I feel connected on some spiritual level.

This reflection helped me craft my own definition:

Authenticity in music is not only how a musician performs but is also how a listener perceives the performance. (Click to Tweet)

More on Definitions

Another creative way to understand a concept is to browse a thesaurus and study the synonyms and antonyms. Consider these from Merriam-Webster:



After a look at these, I would certainly not prefer to listen to music that sounds fake or phony, nor would I want my performances to come off that way!

Alright, let's see what were listening to.


Can you hear authenticity in music?

scrabble, scrabble pieces, lettering, letters, wood, scrabble tiles, white background, words, quote, listen, listen more, attend, attentive, mindfulness,
Photo by Brett Jordan / Unsplash

Let's test it.

Think about these attributes: real, personality, spirit, character, original, obsolete, and authoritative.

  1. Find a recording of a musician, piece, or song that you love.
  2. Listen for the characteristics from above.
  3. Do you feel any of them while listening? Can you sense their presence?

You might perceive the answers on a sliding scale, and that's okay. The point is that you become more aware of what might be authentic to you. This is a skill you certainly want to sharpen because why would we honor inauthentic things?

Related: This piece I composed recently feels authentic, to me. But, does my audience feel the same way?

Teach and Learn

How do you teach music authenticity?

Photo by Jason Rosewell / Unsplash

Authenticity is tough to teach because it requires us to judge another person's playing–whether good or bad. And, although the practice of judgement is important as one moves forward, it is something we should keep private or in conversation with a trusted friend. As we judge authenticity, we do not want to hurt others while doing so.

We cannot advance musically without pointing out inauthenticity. (Click to Tweet)

Authenticity is what reveals the unique qualities about each of us. As any musician sharpens their ears, real maturity is when you can hear music clearly and sense it's beauty, all at the same time.

Because, if the beauty of music is not authentic, it may lack original depth, soul, expression, beauty, or passion.

In the Movies

My wife and I just watched the new Mulan movie on Disney+. Although it was much different from the original, we were inspired to talk about the folktale's lessons.

This picture was taken in autumn 2013. The light was magical that day, the colours mesmerising. The conditions were perfect to discover the Great Wall. This picture is one of my favourites ever, it was my desktop background for so long!
Photo by Violette Filippini / Unsplash

Spirit and traditions are much different in Asia than the United States. So, it raises a question:

How does China and other Asian cultures perceive authenticity differently than those in America?

See this Tweet where I replied to Nick Wignall's question about our “true self.”

Similar questions come to mind like:

  • What is our Chi?
  • What is the spirit of our ancesters?
  • What does loyal, brave, and true mean to us?
Answers to our questions are omnipresent, we just have to look for them. (Click to Tweet)

Like we did with Disney's Mulan, use clues and evidence in other disciplines like acting, storytelling, and art to discover what authenticity means to you.

Musical Examples

Ode to Life” by Don Pullen written in honor of Maurice Quesnel is, in my opinion, an authentic composition, improvisation, and performance.

Vintage piano player
Photo by Darius Soodmand / Unsplash

Listen on Apple Music or Spotify.

Listen on Apple Music

Pullen’s performance feels like it came from a deep and emotional place. He’s not just playing the notes, he’s feeling them in real time.  

Hear more of Don Pullen on NPR in this episode, Don Pullen On Piano Jazz.

Activity for You

Let’s see how we feel as a community.

What authentic music do you listen to? How do you know it's authentic?

Let’s be open—do you have a personal experience, recording, or story that includes authentic music?

Let me know in this Twitter thread.

Let's continue a “real” conversation about music authenticity.

Send me a message on social media–private or public.

Until we jam again, keep plucking.

Additional Reading

What Makes Music Authentic: A Detailed Analysis of Thoughts
Have you ever thought about what makes music authentic? Find out the factors that differentiate between authentic and inauthentic music.
Why Songwriters Should Be Embracing Authenticity - Not Trends - TuneCore
Patrick McGuire offers songwriters some advice for creating meaningful music and why authenticity matters.